AI and the Peer-review Process: Transforming Research Quality Assessment and Ethical Implications

AI’s integration into academic research has prompted a reevaluation of traditional peer-review processes. This paper delves into the significance of peer review in mass communication research and explores AI’s role in enhancing its efficiency. It outlines objectives centered around AI-based tools for manuscript screening, improving peer-review efficiency, ethical implications, challenges, case studies, and recommendations. Automated plagiarism detection, identifying research misconduct, and analyzing methodological rigor are highlighted as AI’s contributions to assessment and screening. Efforts to streamline peer-review processes include AI-assisted reviewer matching, communication facilitation, and expedited editorial triaging. Ethical concerns encompass AI bias, academic freedom implications, and data privacy issues. Challenges such as ensuring transparency and addressing resistance are discussed alongside case studies illustrating AI applications and their impact on research quality. The paper concludes by summarizing key findings, emphasizing AI’s potential to enhance research quality, and urging consideration of ethical dimensions in peer review.

Priyam Verma, Research Scholar,, School of Media and Communication Studies, Galgotias University

Click here for the full paper



Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

About us

Journal of Media Scholars

Greetings!!

Media professionals around the world engage in active information and perspective sharing across different platforms. Nevertheless, scholarly articles face certain limitations, particularly in regions like the global south. This is especially evident for scholars specializing in Modern Indian Languages, who lack sufficient academic journals that offer opportunities to contribute their insights and address media, communication, and societal issues.

Our objective is to address this gap by publishing research papers in Hindi and English twice a year. Our journal covers a broad range of topics within Media Studies and related fields, and it undergoes a rigorous peer-review process. Media Scholar began in January, 2023 in the online mode as a tri-annual journal. It later became Bi-annual in 2024. By offering a bilingual (Hindi & English) platform for Mass Communication, we aim to serve students, faculty members, and professionals within the industry.

Newsletter